Important judgment on legal professional privilege and the “iniquity exception” to privilege

News & Judgments
12 January 2018

Judgment was delivered in the Commercial Court on 11 January in the case of Accident Exchange Ltd v McLean and others [2018] EWHC 23 (Comm).  The judgment considers the “iniquity exception” to legal professional privilege and, in particular, the limited circumstances in which a lawyer’s client may lose the protection of privilege because of the (alleged) wrongdoing of another person.  In the litigation, the Claimants are alleging that a company which provided evidence for litigation, and a number of firms of solicitors, conspired to produce false or misleading evidence in relation to thousands of County Court case; allegations which are denied.  The Claimants sought inspection of case files of the solicitors despite the fact that much of the content was prima facie subject to privilege for their lay clients and those clients’ insurers.  Sir Andrew Smith refused the Claimants’ application and, in the course of his judgment, he analysed and elaborated on the authorities governing loss of privilege through the alleged iniquity of a third party.

Jonathan Hough QC acted for insurers who participated in the hearing to protect their privilege and that of their insureds.  Jamie Smith QC, Miles Harris and Mark Cullen are representing two of the Defendants in the substantive litigation.

The judgment can be read here.

Related People

Jonathan Hough KC

Call: 1997 Silk: 2014

Jamie Smith KC

Call: 1995 Silk: 2015

Miles Harris

Call: 2003

Mark Cullen

Call: 2013



Popular resources

Four Fundamentals of Limitation Periods in Contract and Tort Claims

By Carl Troman, Barrister and Mediator at 4 New Square Four key points…

Discover more

Stay of proceedings before serving a claim form

What should claimants do when limitation is about to expire? Noting…

Discover more

Why are there so many cases against lawyers for contempt of court?

There has been a spate of cases in the past couple of…

Discover more

If you would like to know more or have a question please talk to our clerks

Portfolio Builder

Select the expertise that you would like to download or add to the portfolio

Download    Add to portfolio   
Title Type CV Email

Remove All


Click here to share this shortlist.
(It will expire after 30 days.)