Lucy Colter and Will Cook successful in duty of care preliminary issue: Multiplex v Bathgate & others

News & Judgments
17 March 2021

Lucy Colter and Will Cook successful in duty of care preliminary issue: Multiplex v Bathgate & others [2021] EWHC 590 (TCC)

Lucy Colter and Will Cook acted for Argo, the insurers of RNP Associates Ltd, an independent design checker, in the trial of preliminary issues against Multiplex Construction Europe Limited before Mr Justice Fraser in the TCC.

Multiplex brought claims against Argo amongst others in respect of the failure of a slipform rig used in the construction of a 40-storey tower at 100 Bishopsgate. It alleged that while RNP had only contracted with the D&B subcontractor Dunne for the concrete package of works to provide independent design checks, it owed a duty of care and/or had provided warranties to Multiplex in providing independent check certificates, raising fact-specific arguments in respect of whether this was a “contractual chain” case together with more far-reaching arguments about the significance of independent checks and the provision of certificates up the contractual chain. Argo sought a trial of preliminary issues in this respect, and after a three day trial in the TCC, the Judge answered both preliminary issues in the negative, holding that RNP owed no duty of care to Multiplex and owed it no warranties.

This judgment is of significance to construction professionals and their insurers, confirming that parties providing independent design checks or design services in respect of a discrete aspect of a construction project will not, without more, assume responsibility to parties with whom they have not contracted to prevent economic loss.

Case note here (by Will Cook).

Related People

Lucy Colter

Call: 2008

Will Cook

Call: 2019



Popular resources

Four Fundamentals of Limitation Periods in Contract and Tort Claims

By Carl Troman, Barrister and Mediator at 4 New Square Four key points…

Discover more

Stay of proceedings before serving a claim form

What should claimants do when limitation is about to expire? Noting…

Discover more

Why are there so many cases against lawyers for contempt of court?

There has been a spate of cases in the past couple of…

Discover more

If you would like to know more or have a question please talk to our clerks

Portfolio Builder

Select the expertise that you would like to download or add to the portfolio

Download    Add to portfolio   
Title Type CV Email

Remove All


Click here to share this shortlist.
(It will expire after 30 days.)