Judgment handed down by Court of Appeal today in West v Stockport NHS Foundation Trust

News & Judgments
17 July 2019

Nicholas Bacon QC (for the Appellants) and Roger Mallalieu (for the Respondents) acted in what has been billed the new “Lownds” case on proportionality.

In a judgment handed down by the Court of Appeal today in West & anr -v- Stockport NHS Foundation Trust, the Master of the Rolls has provided the guidance which the profession has been seeking since the introduction of new test of proportionality in April 2013. Although the case directly concerns the recovery of after the event insurance premiums in clinical negligence cases, the Court of Appeal has made a point of taking the opportunity to explain how CPR 44.3(2) is to work and be applied by judges assessing costs. Of critical importance for the future is the court’s guidance that where there are items of costs “which are fixed and unavoidable, or which have an irreducible minimum, without which the litigation could not have been progressed”, they will not be reduced on the grounds of proportionality.” Links to the judgments can be found here and here.

Related People

Nicholas Bacon KC

Call: 1992 Silk: 2010

Roger Mallalieu KC

Call: 1998 Silk: 2020



Popular resources

Four Fundamentals of Limitation Periods in Contract and Tort Claims

By Carl Troman, Barrister and Mediator at 4 New Square Four key points…

Discover more

Stay of proceedings before serving a claim form

What should claimants do when limitation is about to expire? Noting…

Discover more

Why are there so many cases against lawyers for contempt of court?

There has been a spate of cases in the past couple of…

Discover more

If you would like to know more or have a question please talk to our clerks

Portfolio Builder

Select the expertise that you would like to download or add to the portfolio

Download    Add to portfolio   
Title Type CV Email

Remove All


Click here to share this shortlist.
(It will expire after 30 days.)