Honesty and loss of a chance: Brearley & Ors v Higgs [2019] 3 WLUK 463

News & Judgments
1 April 2019

“Loss of a chance” is a hot topic in professional negligence at present. Recent disputes over the doctrine have included the debate over whether a Claimant has to prove that he could honestly have brought his “lost” claim on the balance of probabilities or whether his honesty merely falls to be considered when deciding whether his case has real and substantial prospects of success. In February, the Supreme Court decided that the Claimant had to prove his honesty on the balance of probabilities.

Last week’s judgment in Brearley & Ors v Higgs [2019] 3 WLUK 463 considers an allied but opposite point: what does a Defendant have to prove about a Claimant’s dishonesty or misconduct? In particular, does a Defendant to professional negligence proceedings who wishes to rely on a third party’s allegations of wrongdoing against a Claimant have to positively asserts the truth of the those matters alleged by the third party? In Brearley the Claimants applied to strike out parts of a defence based on allegations made by the Claimant’s former employers. The application was refused by the Master and then defeated on appeal. The case shows that a defendant does not have to positively assert the truth of matters emanating from a third party in order to pray them in aid.

Helen Evans of 4 New Square (instructed by RPC and led by Michael Pooles QC) represented the Defendants.

The decision is considered by Clare Dixon of 4 New Square here.

Related areas

Related People

Clare Dixon KC

Call: 2002 Silk: 2021

Helen Evans KC

Call: 2001 Silk: 2022



Popular resources

Four Fundamentals of Limitation Periods in Contract and Tort Claims

By Carl Troman, Barrister and Mediator at 4 New Square Four key points…

Discover more

Stay of proceedings before serving a claim form

What should claimants do when limitation is about to expire? Noting…

Discover more

Why are there so many cases against lawyers for contempt of court?

There has been a spate of cases in the past couple of…

Discover more

If you would like to know more or have a question please talk to our clerks

Portfolio Builder

Select the expertise that you would like to download or add to the portfolio

Download    Add to portfolio   
Title Type CV Email

Remove All


Click here to share this shortlist.
(It will expire after 30 days.)